Best Years For Nissan Murano: Ranked Models For Reliability And Value
The Nissan Murano has carved a distinct niche in the highly competitive mid-size crossover SUV segment, appealing to drivers who prioritize distinctive styling, a comfortable ride, and reliable V6 power. However, with multiple generations and numerous model years on the market, prospective buyers often face the challenge of discerning which specific Murano iterations offer the best long-term value, reliability, and desirable features without encountering common pitfalls. This comprehensive guide will rank and curate the best years for the Nissan Murano, providing essential, must-know insights into their performance, features, and potential issues, enabling you to make an informed purchasing decision.
Understanding The Nissan Murano Lineage: An Overview Of Its Evolution
📤 Share Image
Since its debut, the Nissan Murano has consistently occupied a compelling position as Nissan’s mid-size crossover SUV. It skillfully bridges the gap between more compact SUVs like the Rogue and larger, more traditional SUVs, targeting a demographic that prioritizes sophisticated styling, a comfortable ride, and practical utility without the need for rugged off-road prowess. This distinct market placement has been a cornerstone of its enduring popularity.
The Murano’s design language has evolved significantly across its three generations: the original Z50 (2003-2007), the more angular Z51 (2009-2014), and the current, boldly styled Z52 (2015-present). The Z50, with its distinctive bulbous form, pioneered a new aesthetic in the segment. The Z51 ushered in a more aggressive, athletic stance, while the Z52 introduced the highly recognizable ‘floating roof’ design and a dramatic V-motion grille, appealing specifically to individuals or small families who value style and comfort above all else. This consistent focus on design and cabin experience has been a hallmark of the Murano throughout its lifecycle.
A defining characteristic of the Murano is its consistent powertrain choice: primarily the venerable VQ35DE V6 engine paired almost exclusively with Nissan’s Xtronic Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). While the VQ35DE is widely respected for its robust performance and longevity, variations and refinements in the CVT over the years have significantly impacted overall reliability perceptions. The Murano has consistently delivered a smooth, comfortable ride, an upscale interior for its class, and reliable V6 power, securing its competitive standing within the two-row mid-size crossover segment. For instance, the original Z50 generation, upon its launch, garnered significant attention for its innovative design and car-like driving dynamics, contributing to strong initial sales figures.
Factors Defining A ‘Best’ Nissan Murano Year: Essential Criteria For Evaluation
To objectively assess and rank the most favorable Murano model years, we rely on a comprehensive framework of essential criteria. These metrics provide a transparent lens through which to evaluate long-term ownership prospects and overall value, offering must-know insights for any prospective buyer.
Reliability and Durability
This is paramount, focusing on powertrain longevity—especially the Xtronic CVT—electrical system integrity, and structural resilience over time. Metrics from J.D. Power and Consumer Reports are invaluable here.
Ownership Costs
We analyze depreciation rates, average maintenance expenses, and fuel efficiency specific to certain model years. For example, the Murano generally experiences average depreciation compared to segment competitors.
Feature Set and Technology
Evaluation focuses on the relevance and functionality of infotainment systems, advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), and creature comforts. A late-model Z51 (e.g., 2014) often presents a better balance of reliability and features than an early Z51 (e.g., 2009).
Safety Ratings
Reviewing performance in crash tests from organizations like the IIHS and NHTSA, alongside the availability of crucial safety features such as the Intelligent Around View Monitor (later Z51/Z52 models) or Nissan Safety Shield 360 (Z52), is paramount.
Common Issues and Recalls
We acknowledge prevalent problems specific to certain years and how successfully they were addressed by Nissan, often referencing NHTSA recall databases.
Second Generation Refinement: The Curated Picks For Reliability (2012-2014 Z51 Models)
From an expert perspective, the latter years of the second-generation Murano, specifically the 2012, 2013, and 2014 Z51 models, represent a sweet spot for reliability and value. This collection of years benefits from critical refinements that significantly improve the ownership experience, making them a must-know selection for potential buyers.
Nissan engineers continuously refined the Xtronic CVT (models RE0F09A/B) throughout the Z51 generation. By 2012, many of the early design and manufacturing issues had been addressed, leading to notably better durability and reduced failure rates compared to the inaugural 2009-2011 models. While no CVT is entirely immune to problems, anecdotal evidence and reports from independent technicians consistently suggest fewer significant issues in these later Z51 models, particularly when supported by a diligent maintenance history, including documented CVT fluid changes every 60,000 miles or as recommended.
These models also benefited from a mature and highly reliable iteration of the VQ35DE V6 engine, renowned for its robust performance and exceptional longevity. Producing a consistent 260 horsepower, this 3.5-liter engine provides strong, smooth acceleration and proven long-term durability when properly maintained. It is a workhorse engine that contributes significantly to the Murano’s reliable reputation.
Beyond mechanical fortitude, the 2012-2014 Murano models offered an enhanced interior and feature set. Subtle upgrades in material quality and the availability of desirable features such as a factory navigation system, heated steering wheel, and a power liftgate provided a premium experience without the added complexity or potential glitches of newer, more experimental technological integrations. This balance makes them a compelling choice.
The value proposition of these Murano years is particularly strong. On the used market, a well-maintained 2014 Murano, for instance, with a documented service history, offers an excellent balance of features, performance, and improved reliability at a significantly more accessible price point than newer models. J.D. Power often rated these years as ‘Average’ or ‘Above Average’ for reliability, marking a notable improvement for the generation and making them a popular and recommended choice for budget-conscious buyers seeking dependable transportation.
By The Numbers (2014 Murano AWD)
VQ35DE V6 Output
City/Highway Fuel Economy
J.D. Power Reliability Rating
Third Generation Advancements: Top Picks For Modern Features And Refinement (2017-2020 Z52 Models)
For those prioritizing modern amenities, advanced safety features, and a superior level of refinement, the 2017-2020 Z52 Nissan Murano models stand out as the top picks. These years represent a significant leap forward in technology, comfort, and overall driving experience within the Murano lineage, offering a compelling selection of features and enhanced reliability.
The third generation introduced a significantly refined Xtronic CVT (model RE0F09B/F). Nissan engineers implemented further advancements, resulting in smoother operation, better simulated shifts that mimic traditional automatic transmissions, and enhanced long-term reliability compared to previous iterations. This CVT, still paired with the proven VQ35DE V6 engine (260 hp and 240 lb-ft of torque), delivers a more satisfying and efficient driving experience. For example, a 2018 FWD Murano boasts an impressive 21 city / 28 highway MPG.
A key differentiator for these model years is the proliferation of advanced safety technologies. Starting with the 2019 refresh, Nissan introduced and expanded its Safety Shield 360 suite, which typically includes Automatic Emergency Braking, Blind Spot Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Lane Departure Warning, and High Beam Assist. Earlier Z52 models (2017-2018) also offered critical ADAS features such as Intelligent Around View Monitor and Forward Emergency Braking. These advancements consistently earned these models strong safety accolades, including IIHS ‘Top Safety Pick+’ ratings for certain years (e.g., 2018, 2019 when equipped with specific headlights) and a 5-star overall NHTSA rating.
Interior technology received a substantial upgrade as well. The NissanConnect infotainment system became more user-friendly, with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration becoming standard from 2018 onwards. This significantly improved user experience and functionality, moving beyond proprietary systems to seamless smartphone connectivity. A 2019 Murano Platinum, for instance, could showcase the intuitive 8-inch touchscreen and even optional ProPILOT Assist for enhanced driving convenience.
The Z52 generation also placed a strong emphasis on enhanced ride comfort and interior quality. The cabin is notably quieter, the ride is plush, and premium interior materials, especially in higher trims like the Platinum, create a truly upscale environment for its segment. These models represent a comprehensive collection of improvements, making them a popular choice for those seeking a more contemporary and refined crossover experience. EPA fuel economy figures for 2020 FWD models consistently hover around 20/28 MPG city/highway, showcasing efficiency alongside performance.
Refined CVT Operation
Smoother, more responsive Xtronic CVT with simulated shifts, improving driveability and long-term reliability.
Advanced Safety Shield 360
Comprehensive suite of ADAS features for enhanced driver and passenger protection, leading to high safety ratings.
Modern Infotainment
Standard Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration from 2018, coupled with an intuitive NissanConnect system.
Premium Comfort & Quality
Focus on a plush ride, a quieter cabin, and elevated interior materials, especially in higher trim levels.
Years To Exercise Caution: Identifying Potential Pitfalls In Nissan Murano Ownership
While many Murano models offer excellent value and reliability, certain years warrant greater scrutiny. This essential section educates prospective buyers on specific model years known to have more prevalent issues, allowing them to make informed decisions and avoid common pitfalls.
Exercise extreme caution with 2009, 2010, and 2011 Nissan Murano models. These early second-generation (Z51) vehicles, specifically those equipped with the RE0F09A Xtronic CVT, are known to have a significantly higher incidence of transmission failure. Symptoms can include shuddering, hesitation, loss of power, or the vehicle entering ‘limp mode’. Repairs or replacements are often costly, representing a major financial risk. NHTSA complaint data from this period shows a high volume of CVT-related complaints, and several class-action lawsuits have highlighted these persistent issues.
Beyond the prominent CVT concerns of the early Z51 models, other potential pitfalls deserve attention:
- Early Z50 (2003-2006) Wear and Tear: As the inaugural generation ages, common age-related issues become more prevalent. These can include worn suspension components (e.g., control arms and bushings contributing to excessive road noise or poor handling), power steering leaks, and interior material degradation such as cracking dashboards or worn upholstery. While these are typical for vehicles of this age, they can add up in maintenance costs. A pre-purchase inspection might reveal a noisy power steering pump in a 2005 Murano, signaling imminent repair needs.
- Specific Known Recalls and TSBs: Always check for open recalls or Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs) relevant to any specific model year you are considering. While the CVT issues are paramount, other TSBs might address minor but annoying issues like power window malfunctions or sensor failures. Utilizing the NHTSA recall database with the vehicle’s VIN is an essential step in due diligence.
- Infotainment and Electrical Glitches in Early Z52 Models: Some early Z52 Murano models (e.g., 2015-2016) had reports of minor infotainment system bugs or electrical gremlins, such as Bluetooth connectivity issues or unresponsive touchscreens. While often resolved with software updates, it’s worth checking if these updates were performed, especially before Apple CarPlay/Android Auto became standard, leading to greater reliance on the native system.
Awareness of these specific vulnerabilities is crucial for any potential buyer, enabling a more targeted inspection and a more informed purchasing decision, especially when considering a popular Murano model from these cautionary years.
In summary, the Nissan Murano has proven itself a popular and attractive mid-size crossover, but discerning its best years requires a nuanced understanding of its generational advancements and potential drawbacks. Later Second-Generation Muranos (2012-2014 Z51) offer an excellent balance of refined reliability and value due to improved CVT designs and a mature VQ35DE engine. Third-Generation models (2017-2020 Z52) represent the pinnacle of modern features, enhanced safety, and improved CVT performance, ideal for those seeking contemporary amenities. Conversely, exercise caution with early Second-Generation models (2009-2011 Z51) due to historically higher incidences of CVT issues; thorough pre-purchase inspections are paramount for these years. Armed with this detailed analysis, we encourage potential buyers to conduct a thorough pre-purchase inspection by a certified mechanic, review comprehensive vehicle history reports, and test drive multiple vehicles before committing. Share your Murano experiences in the comments!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most common problem with a Nissan Murano?
The most widely reported issue, particularly in the 2009-2011 Second Generation (Z51) Muranos, involves the Xtronic Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). Owners frequently experience shuddering, whining noises, loss of power, or complete transmission failure. While Nissan has made improvements, it remains a critical component to inspect in used models.
Are Nissan Muranos expensive to maintain?
Nissan Muranos generally have average ownership costs for their class. Routine maintenance, such as oil changes and tire rotations, is comparable to other mid-size SUVs. However, major repairs, particularly related to the CVT or advanced safety sensors in newer models, can be costly. Regular fluid changes for the CVT are crucial to prolong its life.
Do Nissan Muranos last a long time?
When properly maintained, a Nissan Murano can last between 150,000 to 200,000 miles or more. The VQ35DE V6 engine is known for its durability. The longevity often hinges on the care of its Xtronic CVT; models with documented transmission fluid changes and good service records tend to last longer, especially the improved units in later model years.
Which Nissan Murano model year has the best CVT?
Later model years of the Nissan Murano, specifically from 2015 onwards (Third Generation Z52), feature the most refined and generally reliable iterations of Nissan’s Xtronic CVT. These units benefit from years of engineering improvements, offering smoother operation and statistically fewer issues compared to the early Second Generation CVTs found in 2009-2011 models.
Is the Nissan Murano a reliable used car purchase?
The Nissan Murano can be a reliable used car, but its reliability is highly dependent on the model year. Certain years (e.g., 2012-2014 and 2017+) offer better reliability scores due to refined powertrain components. Crucially, a pre-purchase inspection focusing on the CVT and a comprehensive service history are essential for any used Murano to ensure a sound investment.
